Note: The online Request to Speak window has expired.
The online Comment window has expired
Agenda Item
3.0 27-0103 Subject: Ethical Investment Policy
From: Members Of The Public, Oakland Divest Committee
Recommendation: Adopt A Resolution Of The Oakland City Council (1) To Amend The City Of Oakland Investment Policy To Prohibit Investments Of City Funds Or Holding Any Investment Or Ownership Stake In Any Companies That Facilitate And Enable State Violence And Repression, War And Occupation, And/Or Severe Violations Of International Law And Human Rights. This Includes, But Is Not Limited To (A) Mass Incarceration And Detention Industries, Including Those Which Use Prison Labor, (B) Security, Defense, And Military Industries, Including Transportation Of Goods, (C) Companies That Facilitate And Enable Violations Of International Law And Human Rights As Part Of The Israeli Occupation Of Palestinian And Syrian Lands And/Or As Part Of Israeli Apartheid;
(2) Directing The City Administrator Or His/Her Designee To Examine The City's Holdings And Future Investments To Assure That The City Complies With This Policy And Set Forth An Implementation Plan Shared At The First Finance Meeting In May 2027;
(3) Directing The City Administrator To Send A Copy Of The Resolution To Governmental Retirement Systems And Local Jurisdictions To Adopt A Similar Investment Policy; On The Finance And Management Committee - Date TBD
I support the ethical investment policy. The City of Oakland should not invest in companies that profit off war, and human rights violations. The City should not invest in securities issued by governments that are known to practice genocide, apartheid & ethnic cleansing.
I urge the Rules Committee to direct City finance staff to prepare a written financial impact assessment, with input from an independent investment consultant, and request written legal analysis from the City Attorney before scheduling this proposal for substantive consideration.
Oakland should learn from Alameda County's experience with its Ethical Investment Policy. Significant financial and implementation questions remain unresolved. Why move forward without addressing those same issues?
This proposal raises concerns about investment returns, liquidity, diversification, and costs. Broad language such as "facilitate and enable" leaves considerable room for interpretation. Who decides which investments are prohibited, and by what standards?
Despite being presented as an ethical investment policy, it reflects an obsessive fixation on Israel while ignoring serious human rights abuses elsewhere. That selective focus has little to do with Oakland's responsibilities.
Oakland needs to attract businesses. A city government focused on international political disputes rather than residents' needs sends the wrong message.
The proposal calls for an implementation plan in May 2027, after adoption. That's backwards. Rules should request these written financial and legal reviews, keep the proposal pending, and reconsider any referral only after the findings are available. That is basic fiscal responsibility.
The proposed Ethical Investment Policy (File 27-0103) raises significant financial, policy, and legal concerns. Before this can be considered, the Finance Department and an independent investment consultant must assess the financial impact and the City Attorney must provide written legal analysis.
Financial concerns:
- The proposal conflicts with Oakland’s existing investment priorities: preservation of capital, liquidity, diversification, and yield.
- The City has not demonstrated the impact on investment returns, diversification, liquidity, or credit quality.
- Divestment would cost taxpayers millions in realized losses and reduced investment income.
- Implementation will be costly, requiring research, monitoring, staffing, and possibly outside consultants.
Policy concerns:
- The proposal specifically targets Israel without establishing comparable standards for other countries involved in conflicts, occupations, or human rights violations.
- Broad terms such as “facilitate and enable” leave uncertainty about which companies are prohibited and who decides.
- The proposal does not clearly explain how it will be reconciled with Oakland’s existing investment policy and delegated financial authority.
Legal concerns:
- Potential conflicts with California’s public investment fiduciary requirements.
- Questions under California laws addressing investment-related boycotts of Israel.
- Potential First Amendment, federal foreign-affairs preemption, and Anti-Boycott Act issues.
I oppose the Oakland Divest’s proposed ‘Ethical Investment Policy’ as it singles out Israel. This does not make sense when there are other local needs to focus on, and could harm Oakland’s reputation by being so singularly focused. Placing politically driven restrictions on investments can and will alienate communities such as Oakland’s mainstream Jews who disagree with the Jewish members of Oakland Divest, and who (although many despise Israel’s current governmental policies) feel a connection to Israel and find singling it out for divestment antisemitic.
Oakland was a leader in the anti-apartheid struggle of the 1980s and should be again in the move to divest from companies and governments which empower mass killing and endless suffering. Yes to a more ethical and binding investment policy.
Fully support this, Oakland should have no connections to destructive or harmful organizations
I support the ethical investment policy. The City of Oakland should not invest in companies that profit off war, and human rights violations. The City should not invest in securities issued by governments that are known to practice genocide, apartheid & ethnic cleansing.
I urge the Rules Committee to direct City finance staff to prepare a written financial impact assessment, with input from an independent investment consultant, and request written legal analysis from the City Attorney before scheduling this proposal for substantive consideration.
Oakland should learn from Alameda County's experience with its Ethical Investment Policy. Significant financial and implementation questions remain unresolved. Why move forward without addressing those same issues?
This proposal raises concerns about investment returns, liquidity, diversification, and costs. Broad language such as "facilitate and enable" leaves considerable room for interpretation. Who decides which investments are prohibited, and by what standards?
Despite being presented as an ethical investment policy, it reflects an obsessive fixation on Israel while ignoring serious human rights abuses elsewhere. That selective focus has little to do with Oakland's responsibilities.
Oakland needs to attract businesses. A city government focused on international political disputes rather than residents' needs sends the wrong message.
The proposal calls for an implementation plan in May 2027, after adoption. That's backwards. Rules should request these written financial and legal reviews, keep the proposal pending, and reconsider any referral only after the findings are available. That is basic fiscal responsibility.
I strongly support the Ethical Investment Policy. We cannot allow the resources of our community to fund war and apartheid for anyone.
The proposed Ethical Investment Policy (File 27-0103) raises significant financial, policy, and legal concerns. Before this can be considered, the Finance Department and an independent investment consultant must assess the financial impact and the City Attorney must provide written legal analysis.
Financial concerns:
- The proposal conflicts with Oakland’s existing investment priorities: preservation of capital, liquidity, diversification, and yield.
- The City has not demonstrated the impact on investment returns, diversification, liquidity, or credit quality.
- Divestment would cost taxpayers millions in realized losses and reduced investment income.
- Implementation will be costly, requiring research, monitoring, staffing, and possibly outside consultants.
Policy concerns:
- The proposal specifically targets Israel without establishing comparable standards for other countries involved in conflicts, occupations, or human rights violations.
- Broad terms such as “facilitate and enable” leave uncertainty about which companies are prohibited and who decides.
- The proposal does not clearly explain how it will be reconciled with Oakland’s existing investment policy and delegated financial authority.
Legal concerns:
- Potential conflicts with California’s public investment fiduciary requirements.
- Questions under California laws addressing investment-related boycotts of Israel.
- Potential First Amendment, federal foreign-affairs preemption, and Anti-Boycott Act issues.
I oppose the Oakland Divest’s proposed ‘Ethical Investment Policy’ as it singles out Israel. This does not make sense when there are other local needs to focus on, and could harm Oakland’s reputation by being so singularly focused. Placing politically driven restrictions on investments can and will alienate communities such as Oakland’s mainstream Jews who disagree with the Jewish members of Oakland Divest, and who (although many despise Israel’s current governmental policies) feel a connection to Israel and find singling it out for divestment antisemitic.
Oakland was a leader in the anti-apartheid struggle of the 1980s and should be again in the move to divest from companies and governments which empower mass killing and endless suffering. Yes to a more ethical and binding investment policy.