Note: The online Request to Speak window has expired.
The online Comment window has expired
Agenda Item
3.0 27-0103 Subject: Ethical Investment Policy
From: Members Of The Public, Oakland Divest Committee
Recommendation: Adopt A Resolution Of The Oakland City Council (1) To Amend The City Of Oakland Investment Policy To Prohibit Investments Of City Funds Or Holding Any Investment Or Ownership Stake In Any Companies That Facilitate And Enable State Violence And Repression, War And Occupation, And/Or Severe Violations Of International Law And Human Rights. This Includes, But Is Not Limited To (A) Mass Incarceration And Detention Industries, Including Those Which Use Prison Labor, (B) Security, Defense, And Military Industries, Including Transportation Of Goods, (C) Companies That Facilitate And Enable Violations Of International Law And Human Rights As Part Of The Israeli Occupation Of Palestinian And Syrian Lands And/Or As Part Of Israeli Apartheid;
(2) Directing The City Administrator Or His/Her Designee To Examine The City's Holdings And Future Investments To Assure That The City Complies With This Policy And Set Forth An Implementation Plan Shared At The First Finance Meeting In May 2027;
(3) Directing The City Administrator To Send A Copy Of The Resolution To Governmental Retirement Systems And Local Jurisdictions To Adopt A Similar Investment Policy; On The Finance And Management Committee - Date TBD
I'm writing to oppose the proposed Ethical Investment Policy, file 27-0103. I'm a resident of Oakland.
Lots of countries are embroiled in awful civil conflicts, which destroy the lives of civilians who just want to live in peace. The proponents of this policy are just concerned about Israel’s conflict. Why? Let’s not sugarcoat it. The only thing unique about Israel is its Jewish character. No Jews, no news.
I served in the US military in Iraq and saw the devastation wars cause to civilian populations. Wars are tragic, and the war in Gaza is no exception. The only war the authors of this “ethical investment policy” talk about is Israel’s. There is nothing neutral about it.
Oakland can stand up for human rights with standards that apply to every country caving antizionists to sanction their favorite Jewish country. Please reject this, and don't refer it to Finance. Thank you.
Dear Councilmembers,
I support Item 3.0, the Ethical Investment Policy, because the City of Oakland should not invest in companies that profit from war and human rights violations. The City should also not invest in securities issued by governments known to practice genocide, apartheid, and ethnic cleansing. Technology, including certain uses of AI, is making it easier than ever to kill people on a massive scale. The AI-aided killings of Palestinians and Lebanese, and the pager explosions that killed innocent people in Lebanon, are horrifying new ways of using technology to destroy human life. We don't trust the companies behind these technologies, or any products that use them. There are so many other companies to invest in, and Oakland should show that we stand for peace and justice for all.
Thank you,
Given all the ways the United States is enabling and encouraging the Israeli government’s violence against Palestine, we have an ethical obligation to advance this resolution and do all we can to stop financially rewarding Israel for its actions. Let us join the people and cities of conscience who have already taken this step. Divest now! Stand with Gaza.
Good morning,
My name is Candiss and I am a long time Oakland resident. I am writing to you today to strongly support that Oakland have an ethical investment policy. The people of Oakland DO NOT WANT OUR TAX DOLLARS SPENT ON WAR, WEAPONS, SURVEILLANCE, or THE GENOCIDAL STATE OF ISRAEL. How can Americans be so cruel to disregard the livelihoods of our siblings in humanity for profit? (Even though the American government loses trillions with no accountability). Please do the right thing and pass this legislation to the finance committee and city council and vote YES in support. And keep ICE outta our communities! Oakland stands united against the American/Israeli fascist occupation! Ethical and sustainable investments NOW.
I'm asking you to take no action on this proposed item.
This item does not serve Oakland residents. Oaklanders want and deserve a well-run city that uses and invests their tax dollars responsibly - but rather than help Oakland in achieving its fiscal goals and serving its residents, this item attempts to hijack Oakland's resources to advance a foreign policy agenda of undermining the state of Israel.
Doing so would provide no benefit to Oakland. Instead, it would waste Council time and staff time, risk worsening the City's credit rating, potentially expose the City to lawsuits, and undermine our efforts to attract new revenue-generating businesses to Oakland (including the Port).
The City of Oakland needs to be using its resources to deliver services and infrastructure for Oaklanders. It does not need to be getting involved in foreign conflicts. This item should be rejected out of hand.
My name is Zach, I’m a resident of Oakland District 3, and I work in Oakland District 2. I ask you to support the adoption and implementation of an ethical investment policy in the City of Oakland, file 27-0103.
I am strongly opposed to the ongoing Israeli occupation and genocide in Palestine. Israel has violated numerous international laws over nearly 80 years, and the United States of America is complicit in those violations. All cities, counties, and states across the country have an obligation to hold Israel to the law and do their part to end Israeli violence.
Our local and federal tax dollars are being used directly to fuel the ongoing genocide. In Oakland, around $6 million of federal taxpayer dollars is sent to Israel annually; across California, that amount is around $609 million.
Investing in endless wars and genocide isn’t just morally wrong - it directly removes needed funds from our communities where they’re needed most. I would rather see our tax dollars be spent on affordable housing, free or low cost healthcare, and quality public education that doesn’t require parents to relocate or pay for their kids to attend a charter or private school.
Cities like Sacramento and Richmond have passed divestment resolutions, and Alameda County adopted an ethical investment policy last October. Please support the adoption of this resolution and be part of this movement to lead the nation with moral clarity and visionary leadership.
My name is Zach, I’m a resident of Oakland District 3, and I work in Oakland District 2. I ask you to support the adoption and implementation of an ethical investment policy in the City of Oakland, file 27-0103.
I am strongly opposed to the ongoing Israeli occupation and genocide in Palestine. Israel has violated numerous international laws over nearly 80 years, and the United States of America is complicit in those violations. All cities, counties, and states across the country have an obligation to hold Israel to the law and do their part to end Israeli violence.
Our local and federal tax dollars are being used directly to fuel the ongoing genocide. In Oakland, around $6 million of federal taxpayer dollars is sent to Israel annually; across California, that amount is around $609 million.
Investing in endless wars and genocide isn’t just morally wrong - it directly removes needed funds from our communities where they’re needed most. I would rather see our tax dollars be spent on affordable housing, free or low cost healthcare, and quality public education that doesn’t require parents to relocate or pay for their kids to attend a charter or private school.
Cities like Sacramento and Richmond have passed divestment resolutions, and Alameda County adopted an ethical investment policy last October. Please support the adoption of this resolution and be part of this movement to lead the nation with moral clarity and visionary leadership.
As an Oakland District 5 community member, I am writing to oppose this proposed divestment recommendation. Not only does it limit investment opportunities when Oakland is in such desperate need of finding, but it also endangers the 30,000 Jewish community members who call Oakland home. The language of this proposed divestment is factually inaccurate and stands to cause more division in our community. It singles out the one and only Jewish state at a time when antisemitism is on the rise both locally and worldwide. Many of us have had to pull our children from OUSD run schools for this very reason and have contemplated leaving the city. This proposal does nothing to improve the quality of life for the people of Oakland or to bring the community together. City Council can better spend its time focusing on how to make the city of Oakland safer and more prosperous. This divestment proposal is antithetical to that goal.
Taxpayer money should go to support human needs, not death and destruction. As an American Jew, I am concerned about how Israel’s actions engender antisemitism and have sowed division among our communities. We are in a climate poly crisis and the employment of bombs and other weapons have hastened the outcomes of global warming. No more money for war, genocide or other anti-human endeavors. Invest our money in green energy now!
I sully support passing the ethical investment policy.
Oakland is an incredible city with an incredibly diverse community and a long history of struggling for justice. Voting yes would contribute to that history by divesting Oakland from war, occupation, and genocide. Cities all over the US are adopting similar policies. Oakland residents know we don't want our dollars invested in killing people abroad. We believe it is fiscally responsible to divest from harmful companies and join cities across the country realizing the same thing. Please vote yes.
Dear members of the Rules and Legislation Committee,
I'm a resident of Oakland, and I'm writing to ask you to oppose the proposed Ethical Investment Policy, file 27-0103.
Here's my main concern. Reject the ethical investment policy.
Here's why this is personal for me. These types of policies are targeting to Jews and make me feel unsafe in my own community. This is not related to what we need to do to make Oakland a great city.
A lot of people in Oakland have friends and family on both sides of this. Fights like this one push everyone into corners and make it harder to talk at school pickup or in line at the store. Local government shouldn't be the one handing out the sides.
Sending this to Finance wouldn't fix any of it. It would just pass the problem along. Please reject it at Rules. Thank you.
Join the ever-increasing list of cities that have recently divested, including Cambridge MA; Providence, RI; Easthampton, MA; Portland, ME; Belfast, ME; Medford, MA; Iowa City, IA, and dozens of local councils across Ireland, Turkey, Norway, Spain, Sweden, France, the UK, Italy, Belgium, and Australia who have passed resolutions that support BDS or that pledge not to deal with specific companies targeted by the BDS movement.
Take action now to end complicity, and build on the growing solidarity movement that reflects Oakland’s community values.
On behalf of your 10,000 Yemeni constituents and the Oakland Muslim community, we ask that you please vote yes and support this ethical investment legislation moving forward. Oakland of all places should not support companies invested in gross human rights violations, prison labor, or the killing of our families and friends through AI-assisted airstrikes in Palestine, Iran, Lebanon, Syria and Yemen. Microsoft's Azure enables the Israeli military to bomb and terrorize our relatives across mutiple countries at the click of a button, with little to no human oversight. This same technology is responsible for the Minab elementary school strike that killed 168 children in Iran.
It was great to see councilmembers Jenkins and Unger to bring forward and support the No War on Iran Ordinance earlier this year, so hopefully we can see the same support for the ethical investment policy being brought forward by Oakland Divest. It would be an insult to the Oaklanders who came before us that supported divestment from apartheid South Africa and Myanmar to not support this and stand on the side of oppression and the crimes against humanity that have deeply traumatized your Muslim, Palestinian, Yemeni, Lebanese, Syrian and Iranian constituents for YEARS. There is NOTHING divisive about standing for justice for the thousands of innocent lives that have been stolen from our communities.
On behalf of your 10,000 Yemeni constituents and the Oakland Muslim community, we ask that you please vote yes and support this ethical investment legislation moving forward. Oakland of all places should not support companies invested in gross human rights violations, prison labor, or the killing of our families and friends through AI-assisted airstrikes in Palestine, Iran, Lebanon, Syria and Yemen. Microsoft's Azure enables the Israeli military to bomb and terrorize our relatives across mutiple countries at the click of a button, with little to no human oversight. This same technology is responsible for the Minab elementary school strike that killed 168 children in Iran.
It was great to see councilmembers Jenkins and Unger to bring forward and support the No War on Iran Ordinance earlier this year, so hopefully we can see the same support for the ethical investment policy being brought forward by Oakland Divest. It would be an insult to the Oaklanders who came before us that supported divestment from apartheid South Africa and Myanmar to not support this and stand on the side of oppression and the crimes against humanity that have deeply traumatized your Muslim, Palestinian, Yemeni, Lebanese, Syrian and Iranian constituents for YEARS. There is NOTHING divisive about standing for justice for the thousands of innocent lives that have been stolen from our communities.
I am strongly in favor of adopting an Ethical Investment Policy to prevent our tax dollars from enabling human rights abuses in any country. Oakland has 20 million dollars invested in Microsoft, which enables ICE repression right here in Oakland, as evidenced by the kidnapping of our neighbor from Highland Hospital last month. Microsoft also enables the genocide and apartheid of the Palestinian people by providing militarized technology to the Israeli military. Please vote yes and schedule this urgently needed legislation to the next possible Finance Committee meeting on Dec 8th.
I strongly support this Ethical Investment Policy for the city of Oakland. Conducting business with companies and entities that profit off of human suffering is both immoral and risky. Companies on the Boycott, Divest, Sanctions (BDS) list rank higher in “risk” index, and have been deemed “controversial” in multiple financial reports. I strongly support this Ethical Investment Policy, as it is both moral and financially responsible.
Countries, cities and states around the world are divesting from genocide and apartheid because it is the moral and fiscally responsible choice. Do the right thing and divest now! Oakland residents do not want blood on their hands!
I strongly support Oakland adopting an ethical investment policy. Why would any rationale, humane electorate or its elected leaders oppose restricting their tax dollars from being lent to companies that knowingly, consistently, and willingly make available goods or services that enable some of the worst human rights violations, such as apartheid or genocide? Oakland already restricts investments in some of the vilest of industries, such as fossil fuels, and has divested from historically oppressive regimes in places like South Africa, Burma, and Nigeria. Why should a state like Israel -- that essentially every reputable human rights organization, scholar, and United Nations body has deemed to be guilty of committing apartheid, genocide, or illegal occupation -- differently?
I'm writing to oppose the proposed Ethical Investment Policy, file 27-0103. I'm a resident of Oakland.
Lots of countries are embroiled in awful civil conflicts, which destroy the lives of civilians who just want to live in peace. The proponents of this policy are just concerned about Israel’s conflict. Why? Let’s not sugarcoat it. The only thing unique about Israel is its Jewish character. No Jews, no news.
I served in the US military in Iraq and saw the devastation wars cause to civilian populations. Wars are tragic, and the war in Gaza is no exception. The only war the authors of this “ethical investment policy” talk about is Israel’s. There is nothing neutral about it.
Oakland can stand up for human rights with standards that apply to every country caving antizionists to sanction their favorite Jewish country. Please reject this, and don't refer it to Finance. Thank you.
Dear Councilmembers,
I support Item 3.0, the Ethical Investment Policy, because the City of Oakland should not invest in companies that profit from war and human rights violations. The City should also not invest in securities issued by governments known to practice genocide, apartheid, and ethnic cleansing. Technology, including certain uses of AI, is making it easier than ever to kill people on a massive scale. The AI-aided killings of Palestinians and Lebanese, and the pager explosions that killed innocent people in Lebanon, are horrifying new ways of using technology to destroy human life. We don't trust the companies behind these technologies, or any products that use them. There are so many other companies to invest in, and Oakland should show that we stand for peace and justice for all.
Thank you,
I support Oakland passing an ethical divestment policy. Resources and tax dollars should be spent on the city, not supporting violence.
Given all the ways the United States is enabling and encouraging the Israeli government’s violence against Palestine, we have an ethical obligation to advance this resolution and do all we can to stop financially rewarding Israel for its actions. Let us join the people and cities of conscience who have already taken this step. Divest now! Stand with Gaza.
Good morning,
My name is Candiss and I am a long time Oakland resident. I am writing to you today to strongly support that Oakland have an ethical investment policy. The people of Oakland DO NOT WANT OUR TAX DOLLARS SPENT ON WAR, WEAPONS, SURVEILLANCE, or THE GENOCIDAL STATE OF ISRAEL. How can Americans be so cruel to disregard the livelihoods of our siblings in humanity for profit? (Even though the American government loses trillions with no accountability). Please do the right thing and pass this legislation to the finance committee and city council and vote YES in support. And keep ICE outta our communities! Oakland stands united against the American/Israeli fascist occupation! Ethical and sustainable investments NOW.
Yes! Pass the Ethical investment policy! No public money to ICE, prisons, or unjust wars!
Thank you!
Sonja Trauss
Dear Councilmembers,
I'm asking you to take no action on this proposed item.
This item does not serve Oakland residents. Oaklanders want and deserve a well-run city that uses and invests their tax dollars responsibly - but rather than help Oakland in achieving its fiscal goals and serving its residents, this item attempts to hijack Oakland's resources to advance a foreign policy agenda of undermining the state of Israel.
Doing so would provide no benefit to Oakland. Instead, it would waste Council time and staff time, risk worsening the City's credit rating, potentially expose the City to lawsuits, and undermine our efforts to attract new revenue-generating businesses to Oakland (including the Port).
The City of Oakland needs to be using its resources to deliver services and infrastructure for Oaklanders. It does not need to be getting involved in foreign conflicts. This item should be rejected out of hand.
Thank you,
Ben Gould
Dear Rules and Legislation Committee,
My name is Zach, I’m a resident of Oakland District 3, and I work in Oakland District 2. I ask you to support the adoption and implementation of an ethical investment policy in the City of Oakland, file 27-0103.
I am strongly opposed to the ongoing Israeli occupation and genocide in Palestine. Israel has violated numerous international laws over nearly 80 years, and the United States of America is complicit in those violations. All cities, counties, and states across the country have an obligation to hold Israel to the law and do their part to end Israeli violence.
Our local and federal tax dollars are being used directly to fuel the ongoing genocide. In Oakland, around $6 million of federal taxpayer dollars is sent to Israel annually; across California, that amount is around $609 million.
Investing in endless wars and genocide isn’t just morally wrong - it directly removes needed funds from our communities where they’re needed most. I would rather see our tax dollars be spent on affordable housing, free or low cost healthcare, and quality public education that doesn’t require parents to relocate or pay for their kids to attend a charter or private school.
Cities like Sacramento and Richmond have passed divestment resolutions, and Alameda County adopted an ethical investment policy last October. Please support the adoption of this resolution and be part of this movement to lead the nation with moral clarity and visionary leadership.
Dear Rules and Legislation Committee,
My name is Zach, I’m a resident of Oakland District 3, and I work in Oakland District 2. I ask you to support the adoption and implementation of an ethical investment policy in the City of Oakland, file 27-0103.
I am strongly opposed to the ongoing Israeli occupation and genocide in Palestine. Israel has violated numerous international laws over nearly 80 years, and the United States of America is complicit in those violations. All cities, counties, and states across the country have an obligation to hold Israel to the law and do their part to end Israeli violence.
Our local and federal tax dollars are being used directly to fuel the ongoing genocide. In Oakland, around $6 million of federal taxpayer dollars is sent to Israel annually; across California, that amount is around $609 million.
Investing in endless wars and genocide isn’t just morally wrong - it directly removes needed funds from our communities where they’re needed most. I would rather see our tax dollars be spent on affordable housing, free or low cost healthcare, and quality public education that doesn’t require parents to relocate or pay for their kids to attend a charter or private school.
Cities like Sacramento and Richmond have passed divestment resolutions, and Alameda County adopted an ethical investment policy last October. Please support the adoption of this resolution and be part of this movement to lead the nation with moral clarity and visionary leadership.
As an Oakland District 5 community member, I am writing to oppose this proposed divestment recommendation. Not only does it limit investment opportunities when Oakland is in such desperate need of finding, but it also endangers the 30,000 Jewish community members who call Oakland home. The language of this proposed divestment is factually inaccurate and stands to cause more division in our community. It singles out the one and only Jewish state at a time when antisemitism is on the rise both locally and worldwide. Many of us have had to pull our children from OUSD run schools for this very reason and have contemplated leaving the city. This proposal does nothing to improve the quality of life for the people of Oakland or to bring the community together. City Council can better spend its time focusing on how to make the city of Oakland safer and more prosperous. This divestment proposal is antithetical to that goal.
Taxpayer money should go to support human needs, not death and destruction. As an American Jew, I am concerned about how Israel’s actions engender antisemitism and have sowed division among our communities. We are in a climate poly crisis and the employment of bombs and other weapons have hastened the outcomes of global warming. No more money for war, genocide or other anti-human endeavors. Invest our money in green energy now!
I sully support passing the ethical investment policy.
Oakland is an incredible city with an incredibly diverse community and a long history of struggling for justice. Voting yes would contribute to that history by divesting Oakland from war, occupation, and genocide. Cities all over the US are adopting similar policies. Oakland residents know we don't want our dollars invested in killing people abroad. We believe it is fiscally responsible to divest from harmful companies and join cities across the country realizing the same thing. Please vote yes.
Dear members of the Rules and Legislation Committee,
I'm a resident of Oakland, and I'm writing to ask you to oppose the proposed Ethical Investment Policy, file 27-0103.
Here's my main concern. Reject the ethical investment policy.
Here's why this is personal for me. These types of policies are targeting to Jews and make me feel unsafe in my own community. This is not related to what we need to do to make Oakland a great city.
A lot of people in Oakland have friends and family on both sides of this. Fights like this one push everyone into corners and make it harder to talk at school pickup or in line at the store. Local government shouldn't be the one handing out the sides.
Sending this to Finance wouldn't fix any of it. It would just pass the problem along. Please reject it at Rules. Thank you.
Sincerely,
Jonathan
Oakland resident D2
Join the ever-increasing list of cities that have recently divested, including Cambridge MA; Providence, RI; Easthampton, MA; Portland, ME; Belfast, ME; Medford, MA; Iowa City, IA, and dozens of local councils across Ireland, Turkey, Norway, Spain, Sweden, France, the UK, Italy, Belgium, and Australia who have passed resolutions that support BDS or that pledge not to deal with specific companies targeted by the BDS movement.
Take action now to end complicity, and build on the growing solidarity movement that reflects Oakland’s community values.
On behalf of your 10,000 Yemeni constituents and the Oakland Muslim community, we ask that you please vote yes and support this ethical investment legislation moving forward. Oakland of all places should not support companies invested in gross human rights violations, prison labor, or the killing of our families and friends through AI-assisted airstrikes in Palestine, Iran, Lebanon, Syria and Yemen. Microsoft's Azure enables the Israeli military to bomb and terrorize our relatives across mutiple countries at the click of a button, with little to no human oversight. This same technology is responsible for the Minab elementary school strike that killed 168 children in Iran.
It was great to see councilmembers Jenkins and Unger to bring forward and support the No War on Iran Ordinance earlier this year, so hopefully we can see the same support for the ethical investment policy being brought forward by Oakland Divest. It would be an insult to the Oaklanders who came before us that supported divestment from apartheid South Africa and Myanmar to not support this and stand on the side of oppression and the crimes against humanity that have deeply traumatized your Muslim, Palestinian, Yemeni, Lebanese, Syrian and Iranian constituents for YEARS. There is NOTHING divisive about standing for justice for the thousands of innocent lives that have been stolen from our communities.
On behalf of your 10,000 Yemeni constituents and the Oakland Muslim community, we ask that you please vote yes and support this ethical investment legislation moving forward. Oakland of all places should not support companies invested in gross human rights violations, prison labor, or the killing of our families and friends through AI-assisted airstrikes in Palestine, Iran, Lebanon, Syria and Yemen. Microsoft's Azure enables the Israeli military to bomb and terrorize our relatives across mutiple countries at the click of a button, with little to no human oversight. This same technology is responsible for the Minab elementary school strike that killed 168 children in Iran.
It was great to see councilmembers Jenkins and Unger to bring forward and support the No War on Iran Ordinance earlier this year, so hopefully we can see the same support for the ethical investment policy being brought forward by Oakland Divest. It would be an insult to the Oaklanders who came before us that supported divestment from apartheid South Africa and Myanmar to not support this and stand on the side of oppression and the crimes against humanity that have deeply traumatized your Muslim, Palestinian, Yemeni, Lebanese, Syrian and Iranian constituents for YEARS. There is NOTHING divisive about standing for justice for the thousands of innocent lives that have been stolen from our communities.
I am strongly in favor of adopting an Ethical Investment Policy to prevent our tax dollars from enabling human rights abuses in any country. Oakland has 20 million dollars invested in Microsoft, which enables ICE repression right here in Oakland, as evidenced by the kidnapping of our neighbor from Highland Hospital last month. Microsoft also enables the genocide and apartheid of the Palestinian people by providing militarized technology to the Israeli military. Please vote yes and schedule this urgently needed legislation to the next possible Finance Committee meeting on Dec 8th.
I strongly support this Ethical Investment Policy for the city of Oakland. Conducting business with companies and entities that profit off of human suffering is both immoral and risky. Companies on the Boycott, Divest, Sanctions (BDS) list rank higher in “risk” index, and have been deemed “controversial” in multiple financial reports. I strongly support this Ethical Investment Policy, as it is both moral and financially responsible.
Countries, cities and states around the world are divesting from genocide and apartheid because it is the moral and fiscally responsible choice. Do the right thing and divest now! Oakland residents do not want blood on their hands!
I strongly support Oakland adopting an ethical investment policy. Why would any rationale, humane electorate or its elected leaders oppose restricting their tax dollars from being lent to companies that knowingly, consistently, and willingly make available goods or services that enable some of the worst human rights violations, such as apartheid or genocide? Oakland already restricts investments in some of the vilest of industries, such as fossil fuels, and has divested from historically oppressive regimes in places like South Africa, Burma, and Nigeria. Why should a state like Israel -- that essentially every reputable human rights organization, scholar, and United Nations body has deemed to be guilty of committing apartheid, genocide, or illegal occupation -- differently?