Note: The online Request to Speak window has expired.
The online Comment window has expired
Agenda Item
3.0 27-0103 Subject: Ethical Investment Policy
From: Members Of The Public, Oakland Divest Committee
Recommendation: Adopt A Resolution Of The Oakland City Council (1) To Amend The City Of Oakland Investment Policy To Prohibit Investments Of City Funds Or Holding Any Investment Or Ownership Stake In Any Companies That Facilitate And Enable State Violence And Repression, War And Occupation, And/Or Severe Violations Of International Law And Human Rights. This Includes, But Is Not Limited To (A) Mass Incarceration And Detention Industries, Including Those Which Use Prison Labor, (B) Security, Defense, And Military Industries, Including Transportation Of Goods, (C) Companies That Facilitate And Enable Violations Of International Law And Human Rights As Part Of The Israeli Occupation Of Palestinian And Syrian Lands And/Or As Part Of Israeli Apartheid;
(2) Directing The City Administrator Or His/Her Designee To Examine The City's Holdings And Future Investments To Assure That The City Complies With This Policy And Set Forth An Implementation Plan Shared At The First Finance Meeting In May 2027;
(3) Directing The City Administrator To Send A Copy Of The Resolution To Governmental Retirement Systems And Local Jurisdictions To Adopt A Similar Investment Policy; On The Finance And Management Committee - Date TBD
My name is Justine Wuebold and I'm an Oakland resident from District 3, in support of scheduling legislation that will strengthen the divestment section of this Investment Policy. I'm also writing on behalf of my organization, Democratic Socialists of America who are co-sponsors of this legislation.
The City of Oakland, along with other cities across California, uses our public dollars to make investments that generate revenue for the city. The City already maintains an investment policy that prevents investments in fossil fuels, tobacco and firearms. We want to ensure these funds are not invested in companies complicit in the ongoing apartheid and genocide of Palestinian people and other peoples around the world whose human rights are being violated due to their identity and belief systems or who are providing humanitarian aid to them.
I ask the city to update its existing investment policy by prohibiting investments in companies that facilitate and enable state violence, war, occupation, repression, or violations of international law and human rights, such as apartheid and genocide.
Oakland has an opportunity here to pave the way toward more ethical investment by saying we do not support these industries and I hope to see this council further strengthen our city's investment.
As an Oakland resident, I strongly support this resolution to update our ethical investment policy, to know that we are invested in the kinds of industries that are reflective of the values and principles we aspire to uphold. To ensure we are investing in the world we want to see.
I've lived in Oakland for over a decade, my family and I currently reside in D6. Our community's prosperity should not come at the expense of others. That should be a bare minimum moral standard that we can all support, and frankly it is morally repugnant to think otherwise.
Additionally, it is clear that what is happening in Palestine is an atrocity and a moral crime and we should not enable it in any way. Those who are submitting comments here denying what is taking place there make me sick to my stomach. History will not look upon them kindly.
I'm a Jewish Oakland resident and I strongly support adoption of an ethical investment policy. The state of Israel does not represent my Jewish voice. Criticism, boycott, and divestment that protests the human rights violations that Israel continues to commit do not threaten me or other Jews. Taking stands against mass violence makes us all safer.
My name is Erin Anderson, and I am an Oakland resident. Oakland absolutely needs to adopt an ethical divestment policy. We as a community must divest our tax dollars from supporting genocide and we must prohibit city investments in companies and financial institutions that enable state repression, war and human rights violations. What we decide to do in Oakland matters. We have the power to amplify the message of divestment because we will make national news with this decision. Do not make us complicit by spending our tax dollars. Thank you for your consideration.
I support adopting to divest. As a person with indigenous heritage, it breaks my heart and boils my blood to see the oppression and violence of colonialism and genocide live in the 21st century. For the UN to literally comdemn the starvation and war crimes.
In good conscience, we must divert our resources. SUPPORT PEACE AND UNITY, NOT WAR, NOT HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS.
You can help end the collective centuries of indigenous violence and genocide. Please do the right thing. Vote yes. Thank you.
As a long-time residents of Oakland, living in District 4, we asking all Rules Committee member, to vote Yes on the People's Ethical Investment Policy and to schedule this legislation to the soonest Finance Committee meeting. We are some of the many people of conscience in Oakland, demanding that we update our ethical investment policy to remove our tax payer money from companies enabling state violence, repression, and/or severe violations of international law and human rights.
This includes, but isn’t limited to:
a) Companies that facilitate and enable Israeli apartheid and occupation of the Palestinian people;
b) Industries of security, defense, and military, including companies that transport military goods;
c) Industries of mass incarceration and detention, including companies that use prison labor.
The Alameda County Board of Supervisors, the Alameda Labor Council, the cities of Sacramento, Dublin, and Richmond and many other local institutions have all approved ethical investment policies. Oakland already knows how to pass ethical investment policy standards through legislation, including investment prohibitions on fossil fuels, firearms and tobacco. We led the nation by divesting from South African apartheid. Now is the time to continue our track record, taking a stand against the ongoing efforts to destroy the people of Palestine, Congo, Sudan, in prisons and anywhere companies are profiting from human suffering.
Bruce Gowdy and Eve Aldridge
Hi, my name is Greysonne. I am writing in support of an Ethical Investment Policy for the City. I grew up in and spent 20 years of my life as a resident of Oakland, and regard it as a City that has always stood behind Social Justice issues. I would find it deeply disappointing if Oakland failed to divest all funds from companies doing business in or benefitting in any way from the Genocide in Palestine. (This includes investing funds in any way in Israel, who are responsible for this atrocious human rights violation and crime against humanity, or allowing Oakland in any way to be a shipping point for anything, such as arms, to aid and abet this Genocide). To me it is akin to learning of ways the United States and American companies were invested in Nazi Germany. I do not wish for the city I spent the biggest piece of my life in to tarnish its image this way. Thank you
Oakland has a long history as a Sanctuary City and in opposing apartheid thanks to leaders like Ron Dellums and Barbara Lee. In order to continue this support, we must establish an ethical investment policy.
This is getting ridiculous. What is happening in Gaza is not a genocide, and Israel is not an apartheid state. For goodness sake, Arab citizens of Israel have effectively ousted the previous government! That is not apartheid, and it’s an insult to South African history to use that term. Stop wasting our time and money with these performative resolutions, and get to work for the city of Oakland. Enough.
I am a community member at Lighthouse Mosque in Oakland, and I strongly support this legislation. I am asking the Rules committee to push the EIP forward to the Finance committee.
Right now, our tax dollars are potentially invested in companies that are profiting off of mass incarceration and endless wars in Palestine, Syria, Iran, and Yemen. Oakland has a long history of standing up for human rights, including divesting from South African apartheid and passing resolutions to divest from firearms and fossil fuels. I now ask the committee to push forward this resolution that will ensure that our tax dollars do not contribute to genocide, war, and human rights violations, right now and in the future. Please do the right thing and push forward the Ethical Investment Policy to the finance committee.
I do not want my tax dollars to fund genocide, prisons, and the military. I want my tax dollars to fund health care, education, housing, public services, and other things that would benefit the broader public and give us greater safety nets. The government's job is to take care of its people and not to harm others.
District 1 Resident. A city whose motto is Love Life - it is abhorrent for us to profit from companies that enable any form of state violence, war, and occupation. The companies and PACs that profit from, and cause displacement and homelessness in the Middle East and Global South, are the same ones that profit from displacement here in our town. Stop further entrenchment into human rights abuses. Israeli apartheid and ethnic cleansing is rightfully called out as a strategic, massive, USA fueled genocide. Perhaps recognition of this atrocity, will finally allow this city to recognize other massive human rights abuses in the world and right here in Oakland.
My name is Nicholas and I’ve been a longtime east bay and Oakland resident. I stand in support of divesting our tax dollars away from genocide by amending Oakland’s investment policy. Unlike some, I believe our money should be focused on improving schools and conditions in our own nation instead of giving it all to another country or using it for corrupt groups like ICE. Why is there pressure from people that focusing our money on improving our own community and not genocide somehow an attack? Please do the right thing and vote yes.
I'm a resident of District 1 and strongly support Oakland establishing this ethical investment policy. We want our money invested in places that reflect our values and support our community, not in genocide, occupation, and violence.
We need to divest from this empire of criminality that is starving and murdering its way to quarterly profits. Decimating communities ANYWHERE in this world with 2000kg bombs - however "profitable" it may be - is no place for the public's money.
The Rules Committee should reject the proposal, not simply refer it to Finance.
Singling out Israel makes many Oakland Jews feel targeted and excluded because of their connection to Israel, even when they disagree with its government’s policies. Jewish members of Oakland Divest do not represent the broader Jewish community. The vast majority of us have feelings and connections to Israel. Once again it is a divisive strategy that will only alienate the Jewish community further from other communities in Oakland. We need policies that will bring us together. Not divide us.
As an Oakland resident, I support this resolution. Our city's fund should go toward our vibrant community, not international conflicts.
Councilmembers,
My name is Justine Wuebold and I'm an Oakland resident from District 3, in support of scheduling legislation that will strengthen the divestment section of this Investment Policy. I'm also writing on behalf of my organization, Democratic Socialists of America who are co-sponsors of this legislation.
The City of Oakland, along with other cities across California, uses our public dollars to make investments that generate revenue for the city. The City already maintains an investment policy that prevents investments in fossil fuels, tobacco and firearms. We want to ensure these funds are not invested in companies complicit in the ongoing apartheid and genocide of Palestinian people and other peoples around the world whose human rights are being violated due to their identity and belief systems or who are providing humanitarian aid to them.
I ask the city to update its existing investment policy by prohibiting investments in companies that facilitate and enable state violence, war, occupation, repression, or violations of international law and human rights, such as apartheid and genocide.
Oakland has an opportunity here to pave the way toward more ethical investment by saying we do not support these industries and I hope to see this council further strengthen our city's investment.
Thank you for voting in support!
As an Oakland resident, I strongly support this resolution to update our ethical investment policy, to know that we are invested in the kinds of industries that are reflective of the values and principles we aspire to uphold. To ensure we are investing in the world we want to see.
I strongly support this resolution.
I've lived in Oakland for over a decade, my family and I currently reside in D6. Our community's prosperity should not come at the expense of others. That should be a bare minimum moral standard that we can all support, and frankly it is morally repugnant to think otherwise.
Additionally, it is clear that what is happening in Palestine is an atrocity and a moral crime and we should not enable it in any way. Those who are submitting comments here denying what is taking place there make me sick to my stomach. History will not look upon them kindly.
I'm a Jewish Oakland resident and I strongly support adoption of an ethical investment policy. The state of Israel does not represent my Jewish voice. Criticism, boycott, and divestment that protests the human rights violations that Israel continues to commit do not threaten me or other Jews. Taking stands against mass violence makes us all safer.
My name is Erin Anderson, and I am an Oakland resident. Oakland absolutely needs to adopt an ethical divestment policy. We as a community must divest our tax dollars from supporting genocide and we must prohibit city investments in companies and financial institutions that enable state repression, war and human rights violations. What we decide to do in Oakland matters. We have the power to amplify the message of divestment because we will make national news with this decision. Do not make us complicit by spending our tax dollars. Thank you for your consideration.
D3 citizen.
I support adopting to divest. As a person with indigenous heritage, it breaks my heart and boils my blood to see the oppression and violence of colonialism and genocide live in the 21st century. For the UN to literally comdemn the starvation and war crimes.
In good conscience, we must divert our resources. SUPPORT PEACE AND UNITY, NOT WAR, NOT HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS.
You can help end the collective centuries of indigenous violence and genocide. Please do the right thing. Vote yes. Thank you.
I am an Oakland resident, and I support this policy. I believe our funds should go towards our community and not genocide.
As a long-time residents of Oakland, living in District 4, we asking all Rules Committee member, to vote Yes on the People's Ethical Investment Policy and to schedule this legislation to the soonest Finance Committee meeting. We are some of the many people of conscience in Oakland, demanding that we update our ethical investment policy to remove our tax payer money from companies enabling state violence, repression, and/or severe violations of international law and human rights.
This includes, but isn’t limited to:
a) Companies that facilitate and enable Israeli apartheid and occupation of the Palestinian people;
b) Industries of security, defense, and military, including companies that transport military goods;
c) Industries of mass incarceration and detention, including companies that use prison labor.
The Alameda County Board of Supervisors, the Alameda Labor Council, the cities of Sacramento, Dublin, and Richmond and many other local institutions have all approved ethical investment policies. Oakland already knows how to pass ethical investment policy standards through legislation, including investment prohibitions on fossil fuels, firearms and tobacco. We led the nation by divesting from South African apartheid. Now is the time to continue our track record, taking a stand against the ongoing efforts to destroy the people of Palestine, Congo, Sudan, in prisons and anywhere companies are profiting from human suffering.
Bruce Gowdy and Eve Aldridge
Please reject this policy. This is harmful to the Jews of our city in a time of the worst antisemitism in decades. Do not cave to the mob.
Hi, my name is Greysonne. I am writing in support of an Ethical Investment Policy for the City. I grew up in and spent 20 years of my life as a resident of Oakland, and regard it as a City that has always stood behind Social Justice issues. I would find it deeply disappointing if Oakland failed to divest all funds from companies doing business in or benefitting in any way from the Genocide in Palestine. (This includes investing funds in any way in Israel, who are responsible for this atrocious human rights violation and crime against humanity, or allowing Oakland in any way to be a shipping point for anything, such as arms, to aid and abet this Genocide). To me it is akin to learning of ways the United States and American companies were invested in Nazi Germany. I do not wish for the city I spent the biggest piece of my life in to tarnish its image this way. Thank you
Oakland has a long history as a Sanctuary City and in opposing apartheid thanks to leaders like Ron Dellums and Barbara Lee. In order to continue this support, we must establish an ethical investment policy.
This is getting ridiculous. What is happening in Gaza is not a genocide, and Israel is not an apartheid state. For goodness sake, Arab citizens of Israel have effectively ousted the previous government! That is not apartheid, and it’s an insult to South African history to use that term. Stop wasting our time and money with these performative resolutions, and get to work for the city of Oakland. Enough.
I am a community member at Lighthouse Mosque in Oakland, and I strongly support this legislation. I am asking the Rules committee to push the EIP forward to the Finance committee.
Right now, our tax dollars are potentially invested in companies that are profiting off of mass incarceration and endless wars in Palestine, Syria, Iran, and Yemen. Oakland has a long history of standing up for human rights, including divesting from South African apartheid and passing resolutions to divest from firearms and fossil fuels. I now ask the committee to push forward this resolution that will ensure that our tax dollars do not contribute to genocide, war, and human rights violations, right now and in the future. Please do the right thing and push forward the Ethical Investment Policy to the finance committee.
D1 resident.
I do not want my tax dollars to fund genocide, prisons, and the military. I want my tax dollars to fund health care, education, housing, public services, and other things that would benefit the broader public and give us greater safety nets. The government's job is to take care of its people and not to harm others.
District 1 Resident. A city whose motto is Love Life - it is abhorrent for us to profit from companies that enable any form of state violence, war, and occupation. The companies and PACs that profit from, and cause displacement and homelessness in the Middle East and Global South, are the same ones that profit from displacement here in our town. Stop further entrenchment into human rights abuses. Israeli apartheid and ethnic cleansing is rightfully called out as a strategic, massive, USA fueled genocide. Perhaps recognition of this atrocity, will finally allow this city to recognize other massive human rights abuses in the world and right here in Oakland.
My name is Nicholas and I’ve been a longtime east bay and Oakland resident. I stand in support of divesting our tax dollars away from genocide by amending Oakland’s investment policy. Unlike some, I believe our money should be focused on improving schools and conditions in our own nation instead of giving it all to another country or using it for corrupt groups like ICE. Why is there pressure from people that focusing our money on improving our own community and not genocide somehow an attack? Please do the right thing and vote yes.
I'm a resident of District 1 and strongly support Oakland establishing this ethical investment policy. We want our money invested in places that reflect our values and support our community, not in genocide, occupation, and violence.
We need to divest from this empire of criminality that is starving and murdering its way to quarterly profits. Decimating communities ANYWHERE in this world with 2000kg bombs - however "profitable" it may be - is no place for the public's money.
The Rules Committee should reject the proposal, not simply refer it to Finance.
Singling out Israel makes many Oakland Jews feel targeted and excluded because of their connection to Israel, even when they disagree with its government’s policies. Jewish members of Oakland Divest do not represent the broader Jewish community. The vast majority of us have feelings and connections to Israel. Once again it is a divisive strategy that will only alienate the Jewish community further from other communities in Oakland. We need policies that will bring us together. Not divide us.