Note: The online Request to Speak window has expired.
The online Comment window has expired
Agenda Item
4.1 27-0177 Subject: Data Center Moratorium Report And Extension
From: Councilmember Fife And Planning And Building Department
Recommendation: Conduct A Public Hearing And Upon Conclusion, Adopt The Following Pieces Of Legislation:
1) A Resolution Adopting And Issuing The Written Report Required By Government Code Section 65858, Subdivision (D), Within Thirty-Five (35) Days Of The Passage Of The Forty-Five (45) Day Interim Emergency Moratorium, Describing The Measures Taken To Alleviate The Conditions That Led To The Adoption Of Interim Emergency Ordinance No. 13899 C.M.S.; And Making Appropriate California Environmental Quality Act Findings; And
As a District 6 constituent and a collective member of Reclaim Our Power: Utility Justice Campaign, I'm writing my support for the data canter moratorium extension. This time will allow the City to continue learning the impacts of data centers to determine a strong and permanent path forward. I also urge the City of Oakland to continue working with community-based organizations and frontline communities during this moratorium to hear our concerns about data centers and to incorporate our ideas and voices when creating a permanent policy (or policies) to protect our communities from the harms of data centers.
On behalf of Reclaim Our Power, an Oakland-based campaign & coalition building the movement to abolish PG&E and replace it with a justice-centered People's Utility, writing in strong support of the moratorium extension. If possible to amend to strengthen this moratorium, please consider specifying a cap of 500 kW load and max threshold of 12,500 sq. ft. when defining a Data Center for purposes of this moratorium. We look forward to partnering with the City of Oakland to conduct meaningful and equitable community engagement. Notably, Care for Community's October 2026 survey of 424 West Oaklanders found that 73% support a total ban on AI data centers. Reclaim Our Power is concerned that data centers would increase Oaklanders' PG&E bills at a time when PG&E has the highest rates in the continental US, when 1 in 4 Californians is behind on their energy bills, and 300,000 families were shut-off by PG&E last year for lack of payment. Black, Latine and disabled people are hit first and worst by energy unaffordability and shutoffs. Data centers would also increase air pollution, noise pollution, guzzle water unsustainably, and overall benefit billionaires and corporations while harming poor, low-income and working families. Pass the moratorium, stand with Oaklanders, not billionaires.
Please extend the moratorium on data center developments in Oakland. If there is a place for data centers in California, it’s not anywhere near the City of Oakland. We need developments that directly support housing and long-term employment needs for city residents.
I am a 3rd year college student studying environmental issues and I support extending the moratorium against AI data center development and also request a permanent ban against AI data centers in Oakland because of all the occuring disproportionate and adverse health issues that are causes by unwanted structures built on land inhabited by many citizens who already face health and social risks!!!!!!!!!!!!
I urge the Council to avoid disproportionate measures driven by public misperceptions of data centers, and instead adopt a model of high-standard, proactive governance.
A blanket moratorium restricts Oakland’s economic future, halting job creation and forfeiting critical sales tax and property revenues that the city urgently needs. Rather than implementing an outright block, Oakland should establish a world-class regulatory framework to safely integrate these facilities. I advise the Council to adopt the following guardrails:
* Acoustic Limits: Enforce strict decibel caps with escalating fines and shutdown terms for non-compliance.
* Ratepayer Protection: Require operators to bear 100% of grid upgrade costs and peak-demand energy spikes, shielding residents from rate increases.
* Clean Energy: Mandate that a set percentage of operational power be sourced from renewable energy.
* Water Conservation: Require closed-loop cooling systems to virtually eliminate ongoing water consumption.
With the right governance, data centers can be a powerful, sustainable engine for Oakland's economy.
I support the extension of the 45 day moratorium and a permanent citywide ban on data centers in Oakland. Please listen to Oaklanders- we do not want Oakland to be a center for the tech industry. We want affordable housing and jobs for Oaklanders who live here now.
The capitalist class, in their development of data centers and unregulated AI, have demonstrated time and again that they have no regard for our health and safety and that they will put profit over people at every turn. There is no evidence that these data centers create and sustain new jobs over time and there is growing evidence of their disastrous environmental impact. Despite the size of the proposed data center downtown, even small centers rely on the support of larger ones for training, essentially exporting their harm to other communities. Oaklanders don't want to be part of a system of environmental exploitation. And we certainly don't want to be displaced when and if Oakland's rents start to increase to accommodate a new tech industry.
Data centers consume insatiable amounts of finite resources, including energy, fresh drinking water, infrastructure, and land. They exacerbate pollution and destroy necessary ecosystems, leaving local communities to shoulder the environmental and economic costs while tech billionaires and investors profit. I believe Oakland needs legislation blocking the construction of data centers entirely, so at the very least please extend the moratorium.
I support the proposal for an extended moratorium on data center developments in Oakland. In addition to the potentially catastrophic environmental impacts (fossil fuels, water use, etc), I am concerned that the wealthy tech companies who seek to build more data centers view Oakland as nothing but empty space to colonize for their own profits, with no regard for the wellbeing of the communities of people living here. There is strong scientific evidence that noise pollution, which data centers are known to produce at extreme levels, is strongly linked with an increase in risk of dementia and other neurological conditions, especially in elderly people. I am also worried that by expanding their footprint into Oakland, wealthy tech companies will rapidly gentrify the most vulnerable areas in our city and create incentives for their high-earning employees to price longtime residents out of their homes. I can easily see a future where the revenue that these data centers bring to the City of Oakland is used to make "improvements" to the surrounding urban areas once longtime Oakland residents can no longer afford to live there, constructing a narrative that gentrification has actually helped Oakland when in reality it has erased and replaced Oakland.
Any data centers that are allowed to operate in Oakland must be held to strict environmental and economic regulations to ensure they have a positive impact on the existing community and cannot exploit Oakland.
I support Fife proposal for 1 year moratorium on Data Centers in Oakland. As these facilities create unceasing noise. Which cannot be abated to a safe level, deafness may result within two mile radius of data centers. Hearing protection equipments snd $3,000. Hearing aids for each resident in proximity to data centers must be cost out as fee to charge the project. No electricity nor water should be allocated from the city for causing hearing loss damage to citizens of Oakland by approving these data centers.
I support the 45 day moratorium and am in support of an absolute city wide ban in the future. Data centers across the country have proven to be considerably problematic for the environment, the communities, and overall livelihoods of all that are exposed to them. With the increasing insecurity of the total global temperature these data centers are going to elevate and activate irreparable damage at a rate that's quicker than we will be able to resolve. I urge this council to pass another moratorium, to do their part in the fight to keep this planet alive.
As an Oakland resident and educator, I implore you to make the responsible choice and adopt the moratorium. This is an important step in considering the ramifications of such a change on the people of Oakland, an the environment we all depend on for survival. The amount of water and energy these data centers use is irresponsible given the age of global climate change and the increasing threat of human caused climate disruptions. If this decision is for short term profit and a few jobs, that is misguided as even data center insiders testify that these data centers only employ perhaps a few local security jobs, while they increase the water and electric bills for the neighborhood. Please support the moratorium and stop these data centers from extracting from our community.
As a District 6 constituent and a collective member of Reclaim Our Power: Utility Justice Campaign, I'm writing my support for the data canter moratorium extension. This time will allow the City to continue learning the impacts of data centers to determine a strong and permanent path forward. I also urge the City of Oakland to continue working with community-based organizations and frontline communities during this moratorium to hear our concerns about data centers and to incorporate our ideas and voices when creating a permanent policy (or policies) to protect our communities from the harms of data centers.
On behalf of Reclaim Our Power, an Oakland-based campaign & coalition building the movement to abolish PG&E and replace it with a justice-centered People's Utility, writing in strong support of the moratorium extension. If possible to amend to strengthen this moratorium, please consider specifying a cap of 500 kW load and max threshold of 12,500 sq. ft. when defining a Data Center for purposes of this moratorium. We look forward to partnering with the City of Oakland to conduct meaningful and equitable community engagement. Notably, Care for Community's October 2026 survey of 424 West Oaklanders found that 73% support a total ban on AI data centers. Reclaim Our Power is concerned that data centers would increase Oaklanders' PG&E bills at a time when PG&E has the highest rates in the continental US, when 1 in 4 Californians is behind on their energy bills, and 300,000 families were shut-off by PG&E last year for lack of payment. Black, Latine and disabled people are hit first and worst by energy unaffordability and shutoffs. Data centers would also increase air pollution, noise pollution, guzzle water unsustainably, and overall benefit billionaires and corporations while harming poor, low-income and working families. Pass the moratorium, stand with Oaklanders, not billionaires.
Please extend the moratorium on data center developments in Oakland. If there is a place for data centers in California, it’s not anywhere near the City of Oakland. We need developments that directly support housing and long-term employment needs for city residents.
Extend the moratorium.
I am a 3rd year college student studying environmental issues and I support extending the moratorium against AI data center development and also request a permanent ban against AI data centers in Oakland because of all the occuring disproportionate and adverse health issues that are causes by unwanted structures built on land inhabited by many citizens who already face health and social risks!!!!!!!!!!!!
Please extend the data center moratorium in Oakland! Forever would be nice but 10 months is a good start.
I urge the Council to avoid disproportionate measures driven by public misperceptions of data centers, and instead adopt a model of high-standard, proactive governance.
A blanket moratorium restricts Oakland’s economic future, halting job creation and forfeiting critical sales tax and property revenues that the city urgently needs. Rather than implementing an outright block, Oakland should establish a world-class regulatory framework to safely integrate these facilities. I advise the Council to adopt the following guardrails:
* Acoustic Limits: Enforce strict decibel caps with escalating fines and shutdown terms for non-compliance.
* Ratepayer Protection: Require operators to bear 100% of grid upgrade costs and peak-demand energy spikes, shielding residents from rate increases.
* Clean Energy: Mandate that a set percentage of operational power be sourced from renewable energy.
* Water Conservation: Require closed-loop cooling systems to virtually eliminate ongoing water consumption.
With the right governance, data centers can be a powerful, sustainable engine for Oakland's economy.
Please pass the moratorium extension and work towards a full ban!
I support the extension of the 45 day moratorium and a permanent citywide ban on data centers in Oakland. Please listen to Oaklanders- we do not want Oakland to be a center for the tech industry. We want affordable housing and jobs for Oaklanders who live here now.
The capitalist class, in their development of data centers and unregulated AI, have demonstrated time and again that they have no regard for our health and safety and that they will put profit over people at every turn. There is no evidence that these data centers create and sustain new jobs over time and there is growing evidence of their disastrous environmental impact. Despite the size of the proposed data center downtown, even small centers rely on the support of larger ones for training, essentially exporting their harm to other communities. Oaklanders don't want to be part of a system of environmental exploitation. And we certainly don't want to be displaced when and if Oakland's rents start to increase to accommodate a new tech industry.
I support extending the moratorium against AI data center development and also request a permanent ban against AI data centers in Oakland.
As an Oakland resident, I support extending the data center moratorium.
Data centers consume insatiable amounts of finite resources, including energy, fresh drinking water, infrastructure, and land. They exacerbate pollution and destroy necessary ecosystems, leaving local communities to shoulder the environmental and economic costs while tech billionaires and investors profit. I believe Oakland needs legislation blocking the construction of data centers entirely, so at the very least please extend the moratorium.
I support the proposal for an extended moratorium on data center developments in Oakland. In addition to the potentially catastrophic environmental impacts (fossil fuels, water use, etc), I am concerned that the wealthy tech companies who seek to build more data centers view Oakland as nothing but empty space to colonize for their own profits, with no regard for the wellbeing of the communities of people living here. There is strong scientific evidence that noise pollution, which data centers are known to produce at extreme levels, is strongly linked with an increase in risk of dementia and other neurological conditions, especially in elderly people. I am also worried that by expanding their footprint into Oakland, wealthy tech companies will rapidly gentrify the most vulnerable areas in our city and create incentives for their high-earning employees to price longtime residents out of their homes. I can easily see a future where the revenue that these data centers bring to the City of Oakland is used to make "improvements" to the surrounding urban areas once longtime Oakland residents can no longer afford to live there, constructing a narrative that gentrification has actually helped Oakland when in reality it has erased and replaced Oakland.
Any data centers that are allowed to operate in Oakland must be held to strict environmental and economic regulations to ensure they have a positive impact on the existing community and cannot exploit Oakland.
I support Fife proposal for 1 year moratorium on Data Centers in Oakland. As these facilities create unceasing noise. Which cannot be abated to a safe level, deafness may result within two mile radius of data centers. Hearing protection equipments snd $3,000. Hearing aids for each resident in proximity to data centers must be cost out as fee to charge the project. No electricity nor water should be allocated from the city for causing hearing loss damage to citizens of Oakland by approving these data centers.
I support the 45 day moratorium and am in support of an absolute city wide ban in the future. Data centers across the country have proven to be considerably problematic for the environment, the communities, and overall livelihoods of all that are exposed to them. With the increasing insecurity of the total global temperature these data centers are going to elevate and activate irreparable damage at a rate that's quicker than we will be able to resolve. I urge this council to pass another moratorium, to do their part in the fight to keep this planet alive.
As an Oakland resident and educator, I implore you to make the responsible choice and adopt the moratorium. This is an important step in considering the ramifications of such a change on the people of Oakland, an the environment we all depend on for survival. The amount of water and energy these data centers use is irresponsible given the age of global climate change and the increasing threat of human caused climate disruptions. If this decision is for short term profit and a few jobs, that is misguided as even data center insiders testify that these data centers only employ perhaps a few local security jobs, while they increase the water and electric bills for the neighborhood. Please support the moratorium and stop these data centers from extracting from our community.